Apache OpenOffice (AOO) Bugzilla – Issue 71710
too many extra lines in 3D objects
Last modified: 2013-02-24 21:22:09 UTC
Chart look bad on OOo 2.1. on Office 2003, it look smooth but on ooo 2.1 look bad with some black line and others.
Created attachment 40691 [details] bug doc
Created attachment 40692 [details] bug doc
Created attachment 40693 [details] bug doc
Created attachment 40694 [details] bug doc
Created attachment 40695 [details] bug doc
Created attachment 40696 [details] bug doc
Created attachment 40697 [details] bug doc
Created attachment 40698 [details] bug doc
Created attachment 40701 [details] bug doc
Created attachment 40704 [details] bug doc
Created attachment 40705 [details] bug doc
Created attachment 40706 [details] bug doc
@utomo: Maybe you should switch over to the realistic Scheme (3D View Tabpage Appearance). So i will close this Issue. Feel free to reopen this Issue if you disagree.
closed as workforme
Sorry I cannot accept it. So I reopen it. Please look at attached screenshot which I took as sample. the chart look really bad. Thanks
Created attachment 40746 [details] test 21 screenshot
Created attachment 40747 [details] test 21 screenshot
Created attachment 40748 [details] test 21 screenshot
Created attachment 40749 [details] test 21 screenshot
Created attachment 40750 [details] test 23 look bad
Created attachment 40751 [details] test 22 look bad
Created attachment 40752 [details] test 23 look bad
Created attachment 40753 [details] test 22 look bad
@IHA: I think its yours.
Hi utomo99. I see you put a lot of effort into testing the chart. Thanks for that. As we are currently reimlpeemnting the whole chart it would make much more sense when you could invest your effort into checking the reimplementation. A preview version is available for download here: http://graphics.openoffice.org/chart/chart.html When you find an issue that is worse than in OpenOffice.org OOo 2.0.4 please start the issue summary with 'new chart:'. Thus we can identify regressions early. When you submit further issues please describe only one problem each. This issue already contains to many different things. And please describe additionally in words what the problem is. I need to guess here already: 1) 3D diagrams are somehow streched and deformated -> should be fixed in the reimplementation with CWS chart2mst3. 2) The extra lines from the example images did not occur in the reimplementation. I give this issue back to you. Please check it against the reimplementation. If you still found something from herein not fixed please submit a new issue with only one problem described. Please also use a more descriptive summary. On the above web site there are also issue queries offered where you can check for duplicates before writing new issue. Thanks a lot.
added me to CC
Hello Iha, Thanks for your explanation. I am currently testing using OOo 2.1 with hope to get better OOo 2.2. I still note yet try the new chart because: - Now I mostly got slow internet connection, and downloading 114Mb is too big, especially if the new version will come soon (when is the milestone 10 planned? ) - I did not understand if the fix for the new chart will become available in OOo 2.2 or not ? In my opinion waiting for OOo 2.6 is too long. If I have chance I will download the new chart test. I did not agree that this resolved as invalid, as I test using OOo 2.1, if this is not exist on new chart, better to close it as WFM, instead of Invalid. and this issue is only about one problems, too many extra lines, which I dont know the result, maybe is the drawing engine which is too old in OOo or other problems causing this. but It is nice when hearing that you say already fixed in new chart. Tony, for a moment can you please help test this, with new chart. is this really good looking at the new chart ? or look like what I attach. Thanks
I set this to invalid because the issue does not concentrate on one probelm and does not describe that single problem. The summary is much to generel thus users who are so kind to search for duplicates have much more effort to guess about your issue. I understand your problem with big downloads but it does not help the chart development when you test the old version.
No superfluous lines on 3D objects anymore. Fixed in CWS chart2mst3 Milestone 10 See http://graphics.openoffice.org/chart/chart.html for download.
The Issue you raised has been marked as 'Resolved' and not updated within the last 1 year+. I am therefore setting this issue to 'Verified' as the first step towards Closing it. If you feel this is incorrect, please re-open the issue and add any comments. Many thanks, Andrew Cleaning-up and Closing old Issues ~ The Grand Bug Squash, pre v3 ~ http://marketing.openoffice.org/3.0/announcementbeta.html
As per previous posting: Verified -> Closed. A Closed Issue is a Happy Issue (TM). Regards, Andrew