Apache OpenOffice (AOO) Bugzilla – Issue 76802
new chart: value "phong" of dr3d:shade-mode behaviour differs from specification
Last modified: 2013-02-24 21:20:37 UTC
In the 3D View specification under chapter "4.2.1 Shading" in line 121: "The phong shading is interpreted as gouraud shading and cannot be set in the user interface anymore." I have created a testcase: 1. Save a chart in a spreadsheet from CWS:Chart2Mst3 where the shading is enabled (Realistic) 2. Manipulate the dr3d:shade-mode="gouraud" to dr3d:shade-mode="phong" in "Object 1/content.xml" 3. Replace the original "Object 1/content.xml" in the compressed document-container with the manipulated one 4. Load the document in the CWS:chart2mst3 office (patched) 5. Activate the chart object (Call Navigator [F5] -> Select the 1st OLE [RETURN] -> Edit / Object / Edit) 6. Format / 3D View 7. Select the "Appearance" tab page Results: - The check-box "shading" is disabled (Bug) - the "Scheme" is "Custom" (Bug) See spec: "phong" value should be interpreted as "gouraud" and that would be "Realistic" scheme and "shading" has to be checked in all cases ("Custom" or "Realistic"). - If the file is being saved now the "phong" value isn't being replaced by "gouraud" in the file format. (Bug) @IHA: you can fix one after another in different issues but all things are in context. Don't know what you prefer.
Created attachment 44771 [details] dr3d:shade-mode:"phong" set in "Object 1/context.xml"
Kyesword set
Matthias just said: Keep the alerts when the minimum ia larger than the maximum. The spec contains a new alert text.
Forget last comment, was intended for Issue 76842
I changed the specification: http://specs.openoffice.org/chart/Chart3DViewDialog.odt line 124-126: changed description for case phong shading line 47: changed condition 'while shading is on' to 'while shading is not off' This should resolve the conflicts with the current implementation.
->Jogi: The updated specification is online, please verify.
ok
closing